The functional movement test ‘9+’ does not predict football injuries

Lower limb injuries are common in professional football and can cause time loss, impaired performance and a significant financial cost to a professional team. Screening tools, like the functional movement screen (FMS) are popular, however there is little evidence that those tools are valid and applicable.

The functional movement 9+ test consists of 11 exercise ‘tests’ designed to assess a player’s movement patterns. It was designed as a tool for clinicians to use to assess athletes with a view to predicting future lower limb injury. In general terms these tests assess a player’s stability, mobility and neuromuscular control. The exercises included in the test battery are: a deep squat, in-line lunge, shoulder mobility assessment, a trunk stability push-up, active hip flexion and diagonal lift, one-legged squat and deep one-legged squat, drop jump test, seated rotation and a straight leg raise. 

This study followed 362 professional players, over a total of 508 player-seasons (216 played one season, 146 played two seasons).1. The participant’s score on the 9+ was collected along with prospective data relating to each player’s injury history and match and training exposure. 

In total, at least one lower extremity injury was sustained by 203 (56%) of the 362 players. Thigh muscle strains were the most common injury type. There was no relationship found between the 9+ total score and the risk of sustaining a lower extremity injury (both overuse injury and acute injuries). This outcome was the same even when adjusted for other risk factors and site of injury. Subsequent analysis did not find any cut-off point that could be used to identify an at-risk player. Age, player position and season were however associated with a significant increased risk of lower extremity injury.

This study shows that the 9+ test does not appear to be a useful tool to predict those at risk of injury.

To learn more about injury prevention strategies that might be useful in football complete the ‘injury prevention’ module.

References
Bakken A, Targett S, Bere T, et al The functional movement test 9+ is a poor screening test for lower extremity injuries in professional male football players: a 2-year prospective cohort study Br J Sports Med 2018;52:1047-1053.

15
Comment

avatar
11 Fils de commentaires
4 Réponses de fil
0 Abonnés
 
Commentaire avec le plus de réactions
Le plus populaire des commentaires
13 Auteurs du commentaire
LucasdrlabelleMark FulcherILIYAN GEORGIEV GEORGIEVFaminu John Auteurs de commentaires récents
  S’abonner  
le plus récent le plus ancien le plus populaire
Notifier de
Min Zaw
Membre
Min Zaw

where can be learn 9 test and 11 exercises ?

Dr Shahnawaz Gazi
Membre
Dr Shahnawaz Gazi

Well all these tests are not done in any functional way for example in soccer what is the functional position, lying is not, so apart from their validity how these tests could simulate the actual body position during the play.

dockees
Membre
dockees

The FMS was not created to predict injury, it was designed clinically as a « discharge » criteria for fundamental movement patterns. So it’s really not surprising that it has not shown validity with respect to injury prediction, but that certainly does not dispell its place with assessing baseline movement [positions]. Like the founder of the FMS, Gray Cook, says it’s like taking someone’s blood pressure; we have « normal » ranges and anything outside of that leads us to determine whether we need to administer other tests to see if anything is actually an issue, or if that is just how their body… Lire la suite »

Mark Fulcher
Membre

I guess the point here is that it is often being used clinically to try to identify those at risk of injury. As you, and these authors suggest, this is probably not useful.

In your practice if you find something that is « outside » the normal range what does this mean to you? Do you do something to try to address that? If so are your doing that to try to prevent injury? To enhance performance? What is this finding telling you?

AMIT AMARESH SAHOO
Membre
AMIT AMARESH SAHOO

can we learn 9+ test and 11 exercises from injury prevention ?

Greg Mirt
Membre

I cannot understand this.

bert.ameloot
Membre

Does muscle weakness predict injury? https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/29533672 There was a weak association with the risk of lower extremity injuries for 2 strength variables: greater quadriceps concentric muscle strength at (1) high and (2) low speeds. These associations were too small to identify an « at-risk » player. Therefore, strength testing, as performed in the present study, cannot be recommended as a screening test to predict injuries in professional male soccer. AND https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/29187349 Meta-analyses revealed a small, significant predictive effect for absolute (SMD=-0.16, P=0.04, 95% CI -0.31 to -0.01) and relative (SMD=-0.17, P=0.03, 95% CI -0.33 to -0.014) eccentric knee flexor strength (60°/s). Despite an isolated… Lire la suite »

Bungu Kakala Jean-Pierre
Membre

Prediction of injuries

Bangoura
Invité

Contrairement au 11 qui était un moyen d échauffement d étirement de streching des exercices préparatoire à l effort le 9+ est un moyen de détection et de prévention des lésions musculaires des lésions osteo
articulaires et des lésions MUSCULO ligamentaires.
En un mot un test pour les sportifs pendant le test médical d usage pour s assurer de la stabilité de la mobilité et du contrôle neuro MUSCULAIRE avant les signatures de contrat.
Ce test nous permet de choisir des sportifs aptes pour les grandes competitios

faminu john
Membre

Very enlightening work.

ILIYAN GEORGIEV GEORGIEV
Membre
ILIYAN GEORGIEV GEORGIEV

Using FMS to predict injuries perhaps is not working possibly (as mentioned Dockees in a previous comment) because it is not designed for that purpose but one can use it (I did it in a little bit modified way) to detect abnormalities in posture and in movement patterns. Later on, based on the findings and the scores, the therapist can prescribe certain exercises to improve stability and mobility. As the injuries happen in a very complicated set of variables, one single tool can not give us a solid evidence for prediction. Finally don’t forget to follow your therapeutic instincts –… Lire la suite »

Lucas
Membre
Lucas

Buenas tardes.
No logro encontrar datos estadisticos de lesiones deportivas en entrenamiento como asi tambien en competencia?
Alguien podria facilitarlo?

muchas gracias.